Statement by “Anarchist Front” on the Killing of Asylum Seekers from Afghanistan at the Iran-Turkey Border

Statement by "Anarchist Front" on the Killing of Asylum Seekers from Afghanistan at the Iran-Turkey Border

Eight bodies have been found at the Iran-Turkey border. The remains are now in the city of Van, out of reach for their families. One of these eight is Reza Nazari, a teenager from Bamiyan, born on September 24, 2009.

His brother recognized him in a video released of the bodies. Reza was the last one seen in that video. Fifteen years old, maybe a little more. No one has yet said who killed these people or how, and this silence itself is part of the story.

We do not want to wait for an investigation to finish before declaring who is to blame. An investigation might pin the blame on a soldier, a smuggler, or a border post.

We say right now: whoever pulled the trigger, that border was built and armed by states. A border is not just a line on a map. A border is a loaded gun, primed and waiting for someone to cross its path. The people walking through the mountains at night are fleeing what these very states created for them: war, hunger, the Taliban regime, and years of expulsion and humiliation in Iran. Then they reached a door that is shut tight, guarded by someone given the order to shoot.

People were killed because they were undocumented. That is the whole story. Under the order of states, a person without papers is not a person. Their death is not a crime; it is merely a “border incident” to be filed in a report. If these exact eight people had crossed that same line with a valid passport and a plane ticket, nothing would have happened. So the border performs its sorting act, dividing those who have the right to live from those who do not. Nature didn’t draw this line. A few men sitting in a few capitals did.

Before the news of these eight deaths had even settled, another name arrived. Ayaz Momand, 19 years old, from Momand Dara in Nangarhar, died in Chaldaran. His family has a photograph showing his body buried under the snow. His brother, Zulfikar, sent this photo to the media because families in this situation have nothing else to show. Ayaz was born on Nowruz in 2007; the day people celebrate the New Year.

Meanwhile, six other families report that their sons disappeared while trying to cross from Iran into Turkey, with no word for days. This means what happened in Van and Chaldaran is not an isolated incident. Every time a body is found, another family is left waiting either for a corpse or a scrap of news.

We do not know if these six people are alive or dead. And this not-knowing is part of what the border does to us. The border simply kills, and then, by hiding bodies under the snow and behind bureaucratic offices, leaves families trapped in silence.

Now, the very same institutions that maintain this border are supposed to investigate the deaths of these human beings. The Van Bar Association has asked Turkey’s Ministry of Interior to launch an investigation. We do not diminish the work of lawyers going to the prosecutor’s office.

But we must be clear: the Ministry of Interior is the very institution that runs the border. Expecting it to prosecute its own killer is pure naivety. We ask nothing of any state neither Turkey, nor Iran, nor the Taliban.

Reza’s brother has asked all three governments to help return his brother’s body to Kabul. We understand he has no other choice, and we do not blame him for this plea. But we must know that these three powers, each in their own way, share responsibility for this death.

The Taliban built a country so unlivable that a teenager from Bamiyan had to flee it. Iran has spent years driving him out through expulsion, exploitation, and humiliation. Turkey has locked its border and posted its guards. And now, all three are expected to “help” a family whose child they helped take away.
The word “tragedy” washes away responsibility, leaving no one accountable.

This is a murder, and its structure is clear. It happens year after year, and every year these states write the exact same expressions of regret. Regular repetition means this is not a mistake or a malfunction; the system is doing precisely what it was designed to do.

What we are saying is that these deaths will not end by petitioning states. People crossing borders must be able to rely on other people: villagers on the other side of the border, drivers, workers, people who were once migrants themselves or will be tomorrow.

Every night, somewhere along this border, someone is there who could open a door, share food, show a way, tend to bodies, and let families know where their children are. States will not do this. People must reach out to one another.

Even in death, they are denied passage. Their bodies are in Van, and their families must beg three different governments for permission to take them back to Kabul. Each of these states demands a piece of paper, a stamp, and a queue. A teenager whose life was “illegal” must have his death legalized before he can be buried.

These details are not accidental. The border does not only work with bullets; it works with fear. States know that everybody found in the mountains sends a message to the thousands still waiting at the starting line: unauthorized crossing has a price. Therefore, these deaths are not a cost to the border regime; they are part of its machinery. Those with money and a passport do not fear the border; those without must pay with their lives.

Wherever inequality exists, the border turns it into death. We will not forget this, and we will not let the names of these eight people vanish into “border casualty statistics.”

Reza was fifteen years old. He was not taken by war, nor by nature, nor by fate. He was taken by this very order that demands we treat it as normal.

For Reza Nazari and the seven others whose names we do not yet know, we hold no official memorials and offer no formal mourning. We state plainly: they were murdered, and those who built the border know it…